Formulas used by this calculator
- Agency fee = higher of (minimum fee) or (retainer + fee % × ad spend)
- Agency monthly cost = agency fee + creative cost per ad × ads + your hours × hourly value
- In-house monthly cost = yearly salary and benefits ÷ 12 + tools + creative cost per ad × ads + your hours × hourly value
- AI tool monthly cost = subscription + extra cost per ad × ads + your hours × hourly value
- Cost per 100 ads = monthly cost ÷ ads per month × 100
Worked example
Illustrative inputs only, not market rates: $20,000 monthly ad spend, 20 new ads a month, your time worth $75 an hour.
Agency at 10% of spend with a $2,500 minimum: the fee is $2,500 because 10% of spend is $2,000. Adding $150 per ad in extra creative and 6 hours of your time gives $5,950 a month.
In-house at $112,500 a year fully loaded plus $400 of tools, $150 per ad and 10 of your hours gives $13,525. An AI tool at $500 plus $25 per ad and 20 of your hours gives $2,500. Change any input and the order can change.
Compare the same output
The calculator holds the number of ads equal across the three options so you compare like with like. If one option would also deliver strategy, landing pages or reporting that another would not, either add the missing work as a cost to the cheaper option or note it beside the result.
Ad spend paid to Meta or Google is the same under every option, so it is left out of the totals. It is used only to calculate percentage-of-spend agency fees and to show each cost as a share of spend.
Use a real estimate for an in-house hire
A salary is not the whole cost of an employee. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that benefits made up 30.0% of private-industry employer compensation costs in June 2026, so a fully loaded cost is roughly salary ÷ 0.70 when benefits are average. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics: Employer Costs for Employee Compensation.
Use a salary from your own local hiring market. If the person will also run email, social or other work, enter only the share of their cost that belongs to paid ads.
Count your own time
Every option needs some of the owner's time: briefing and approving an agency, managing a hire, or reviewing an AI tool's proposals. That time has a cost even when no invoice arrives. Use your own honest estimate for each option rather than assuming any one of them is hands-off.
The days-to-first-live-ads fields are your estimates from each provider's onboarding plan or your hiring timeline. The calculator repeats them beside the cost so both sit in one view; it does not predict them.
Common questions
Which option is best?
The calculator only compares cost and your estimate of speed. Quality of the ads, results, accountability and how much you learn differ by provider and by person. Shortlist on cost, then run a time-boxed pilot with a clear success measure.
Where do the example numbers come from?
They are illustrative. The fully loaded in-house example uses the BLS benefits share described above; the agency and AI tool values are examples, not typical market prices. Replace every value with real quotes.
How do I handle a fee that changes with spend?
Enter the percentage in the agency fee field. For an AI tool priced as a percentage of spend, calculate that amount at your spend level and add it to the subscription field.
